What They Say: "Laura Mercier Caviar Eye Liner delivers long-lasting pure colour with a rich texture similar to Kohl Eye Pencils.

• Ideal formula applies effortlessly, & is mistake-proof


• Never drops colour onto the cheek or face


• Buildable pigment allows inifinite looks


• Use wet or dry for a smoky look

Jen's Experience: I was drawn to this eyeliner first for the rich black color (and being made by Laura Mercier certainly didn't hurt). I was a little disappointed when I first started using it. Wet or dry, it goes on very lightly -- you really have to layer it on to get any appreciable color to it. So, I guess in that respect, it's totally mistake-proof. I got the best color results using the Laura Mercier Wet/Dry Definer Brush that I got last year. It does blend nicely and makes it very easy to get the smoky eye look going on. Unfortunately, it does tend to smear a little if you wipe your eyes, so I tend avoid this one when I'm going to be staring at a computer screen all day. Otherwise, it does a pretty nice job of staying put and lasting throughout the day. Any doubts that I've had about it have been erased just by all the compliments I get when I wear it.

Retail Price: $22.00 (LauraMercier.com)

Rating: